Captive insurance is essentially a type of self-insurance that allows a company to meet its unique risk management needs. Captives can be a good idea because they might offer lower costs, significant tax advantages, underwriting profits, and greater control over coverage and claims decisions. They are also helpful if the commercial insurance market can’t provide coverage for certain risks. However, there are disadvantages to consider, including the potential to be underinsured or have a poorly drafted policy. One of the great benefits of captive insurance ownership is access to valuable risk insights. Captive insurance programs generate detailed claims data specific to each business’s risk profile.
Unlike traditional insurance, which is purchased from a third-party insurer, captive is a form of self-insurance. Under this arrangement, your company creates a subsidiary of itself that writes and covers its own insurance policies. Each business owner has their own definition of a substandard return on investment. Gauging a captive’s value primarily on its ability to earn a minimum ROI is a faulty analysis.
- There are many significant advantages to captive insurance ownership, but what are the downsides?
- While setting up a captive can be challenging, third-party captive professionals can help companies navigate the process and avoid costly mistakes.
- Since the reinsurance market tends to be experience rated (premiums closely reflect the loss history of the insured), a reinsured risk of a captive insurer might face premium increases sooner than a commercially insured risk.
- Captive insurance ownership offers customized coverage, control over risk management, long-term cost savings, and valuable risk insights.
A captive insurance company is one that is owned by the business or businesses it insures. Unlike mutual insurance companies, which are also owned by their policyholders (who may number in the many thousands), captive insurance companies are both owned and controlled by policyholders. However, a captive insurance company is subject to state regulations just like other insurance companies. Captive insurance is structured in a way where the insurance company which issues policies is wholly-owned and controlled by those it insures.
Anyone who purchases captive insurance must be able and willing to invest their own resources into the policy. That is because they have control and ownership of the company and earn benefits from its overall profitability. Navigating the complexities of buying or selling captives, especially in sectors with extensive and long-term liabilities like pharmaceuticals, chemicals, or energy and mining requires expert guidance. Boards of directors will be looking for the input from professional advisory firms like SRS. The decision to buy or sell a captive insurance company isn’t made that often but can be a significant strategic opportunity under the right conditions.
That action may save some cash for the insurers, but it can also cause services to be inadequate or inconsistent. The decision to buy or sell a captive insurance company carries significant strategic weight. Throughout the process, never forget the importance of reputation management. In both buying and selling, foreseeing and managing reputational risks is essential for all stakeholders. Because the entity is essentially self-insured, it needs to raise a substantial amount of capital to keep in reserve to pay for claims. If the entity underestimates its need for protection, or experiences a catastrophic loss, it may not have the funds on hand to provide adequate coverage.
It is, therefore, important to understand the business’ maximum possible capital requirement based on any given policy year. Captive insurance programs have been popular among business’largest corporations https://1investing.in/ since they were first created in the 1950s. As we enter2020, however, captives are enjoying a resurgence as a growing solution forbusinesses of all sizes trying to think outside the box.
Why Are There Multiple Businesses in a Group Captive?
Wordfence is a security plugin installed on over 4 million WordPress sites. The owner of this site is using Wordfence to manage access to their site. Julia Kagan is a financial/consumer journalist and former senior editor, personal finance, of Investopedia. What makes sense for one organization may not work for another, and this is certainly true when it comes to captives.
Understanding a Captive Agent
A captive insurance company operates in a similar way to a traditional property and casualty insurance company. A captive issues policies, processes claims, follows all applicable regulations, files a property and casualty insurance company income tax return, and has profits, if profitable, available to the insurance company owners. The difference is, with an insured-owned captive insurance company, the captive owner(s) decide whether or not to retain or distribute the company’s profits. With a traditional insurance company, the insurer and its shareholders, rather than the insureds, retain the profits. Although this benefit is usually reserved for non-fronted captive insurance, it does apply to the industry as a whole.
Additional Pros of Captive Insurance
While the main reason for captive insurance is risk management, an ancillary benefit for businesses is that they stand to profit if the company’s underwritings are sound. Captive insurance companies offer a way for companies to control costs, reap tax benefits, and cover risks that commercial insurance companies might be unable or unwilling to insure. While setting up a captive can be challenging, third-party captive professionals can help companies navigate the process and avoid costly mistakes. The parent company pays insurance premiums to its captive insurance company and seeks to deduct these premiums in its home country, often a high-tax jurisdiction.
At the outset of 2020, risk professionals who were trying to purchase or renew insurance policies had to navigate an increasingly hardening insurance market characterized by higher rates in almost all lines. The coronavirus pandemic and natural catastrophe losses have only made matters worse. Captive insurance owners may face liquidity concerns if they experience a sudden surge in claims or catastrophic events.
Your access to this site has been limited by the site owner
Ownership ceases when insurance lapses, such as when the business owner no longer needs coverage and stops paying for it. In a more recent example, the state of Tennessee launched its own captive insurance company in 2022 to cover state-owned buildings and contents, including Tennessee’s public college campuses, as well as general disadvantages of captive insurance liability. The captive insures property valued at $31.4 billion as of July 2022. Some risks could result in substantial expenses for the captive insurance company, potentially leading to bankruptcy. Single events are less likely to bankrupt a large private insurer because of the diversified pool of risk that they hold.
Companies that acquire multiple captives through mergers or acquisitions may find overlaps in coverage. Selling redundant captives can streamline operations and reduce overall costs and capital consumption. If you’re considering purchasing a captive, the first steps are assessing the captive’s financial health, understanding its risk profile, its state of regulatory compliance, and valuating its assets and liabilities. A thorough due diligence process will examine closely all aspects of the captive—from its financial records, its claims experience, to its governance history. For example, if the fronting or ceding company each shares 50 percent of the risks, the fronting or ceding company then retains 50 percent of the premiums. A typical quota share agreement that falls within the Internal Revenue Service safe harbor rules for risk shifting and risk distribution is one where at least 50 percent of the risk must be shared.
If they are paid out as losses, then it doesn’t count toward the income and is not generally taxed. This structure permits the parent company to pay a premium to its captive and, in return, receive what is essentially an accelerated tax deduction if everything comes together correctly. Although access to reinsurance has been increasing since the 1990s, reducing the benefits of captive insurance in some ways, there is still an advantage here.
Here’s what you need to consider when deciding if one of these captive insurance options is right for you. A change in the business plan or a merger might result in the captive subsidiary being placed in a run-off mode, and the related expenses produce no current economic benefit. Depending on the risk involved, a wide range of sophisticated, analytical tools can be employed to help calculate IBNR (incurred but not reported) losses.
With captive insurance, a business can provide its own coverage, offering better protection against the types of risks the business is most likely to face as well as potential financial benefits for the business owners. Captive insurance is also sometimes promoted as a tax shelter, but using it that way has its hazards. With captive insurance, the business owner owns the company that insures their business. This gives the business owner direct control over risk and a strong motivation to manage risk effectively. The fact that premiums are paid in advance represents a lost opportunity to earn investment income.